For an island its size, Green Turtle Cay offers a relatively wide range of dining options. They include:
McIntosh Restaurant and Bakery – Serving breakfast, lunch and dinner seven days a week, McIntosh is located on the right as you come down the hill into the settlement. Daily specials are posted outside and a full menu is also available. Denise McIntosh makes some of the best desserts on the cay — our favourites are her key lime pie and guava cheesecake. Friday night at McIntosh is Lobster Fest, with Bahamian lobster cooked a dozen different ways.
MoMo’s Suga’ Shack is the most recent addition to New Plymouth’s culinary offering. Melissa “Mo Mo” Albury serves fresh coffee, delicious cakes and pastries, sandwiches, quiche, fresh-baked bread, ice cream, milkshakes and more. Mo Mo’s is open daily except Sunday.
Two Shortys – On the western end of Crown Street, which runs parallel to the settlement’s south shore, Two Shortys offers great Bahamian takeout food. They also have a few picnic tables if you’d prefer to eat in.
Sundowners Bar & Restaurant – Further west on Crown Street, Sundowners Restaurant is open on weekends, offering a mix of Bahamian and American dishes. (The night we went, they had a great assortment of fresh, local seafood.) Just beyond the restaurant, on the waterfront, Sundowners Bar is open daily and serves a selection of pub-type food.
Plymouth Rock – You have to get there early to get a seat in this tiny cafe, but it’s worth it. Breakfast and lunch are served daily except Sunday. Friday and Saturday nights, visitors and locals gather at Plymouth Rock for cocktails and conversation. The restaurant is near the freight dock at the western end of Parliament Street.
Harvey’s – Situated on the shore of Settlement Creek, Harvey’s serves lunch and dinner daily except Sunday. Specials are posted on a board out front, with a surprisingly varied menu also available. Mondays are pizza and wing night and they occasionally offer Italian, steak and rib, and sushi nights. You can dine inside the air-conditioned restaurant or outside on the beach.
Miss Emily’s Blue Bee Bar – Though many Bahamian establishments have attempted to recreate the Goombay Smash cocktail, only its inventor, the late “Miss Emily” Cooper and her family members know the real recipe. Since Miss Emily’s passing, her daughter, Violet, and granddaughter, Misty, operate her world-famous Blue Bee Bar. In recent years, they’ve added a charming little restaurant, adjacent to the bar. Miss Emily’s is located across from the basketball court in town.
Wrecking Tree – Just a few minutes’ walk east of the town ferry dock, the Wrecking Tree offers Bahamian fare for dining in or takeout. Their screened dining porch offers a terrific view of Settlement Creek.
Pineapples – One of the best spots from which to watch tropical sunsets, Pineapples offers casual dining beside a saltwater pool and, on Fridays, live music. To get to Pineapples, turn north at the Wrecking Tree and follow the signs.
Just a few minutes north of the settlement is the Lizard Bar and Grill at the Leeward Yacht Club. Perched on a rise overlooking Black Sound, the Lizard is a lovely, breezy spot to enjoy a casual lunch or sunset dinner. There’s a great pool for swimming and lounging, and some evenings, they offer live music.
The Green Turtle Club offers a large, screened dining porch plus a slightly more formal indoor dining room. I’m especially partial to their tuna sashimi appetizer and their black and white tuna entrée. Breakfast, lunch and dinner are served seven days a week.
Also serving three meals daily is Bluff House’s nautical-themed Jolly Roger Restaurant, located on the White Sound side of the property. Over the hill, on the shore of the Sea of Abaco, is the relatively new Tranquil Turtle Beach Bar.
A few notes about dining in Green Turtle Cay:
- Some restaurants automatically add a 15% gratuity, others don’t. We’ve found that even within the same restaurant, some servers add the tip while others don’t, so best to make a habit of checking the bill. There is no tax on restaurant meals in the Bahamas, so if you see an amount indicated as “tax”, it’s almost certainly a gratuity.
- The dress code for most places on the cay is fairly casual, though the Green Turtle Club tends to be slightly more formal. At a minimum, most require shoes and some sort of cover up.
- Most restaurants use either rain water or city water. Theoretically, both are safe to drink, though most locals don’t recommend drinking the city water and local wisdom says rain water can cause stomach upset if you’re not used to drinking it. Long story short, best to err on the side of caution and ask for bottled water.
- The above descriptions reflect current restaurant operating hours and offerings. These are subject to change, depending on the season.